While I still think that less
bureaucracy would be a great step towards improving our quality of life, I
really couldn’t think of any way to make this work at all. So instead, I’m
going to home in a little more on not making college mandatory (Yes it’s not actually mandatory, but it may as well
be) because I feel like that is something that we could realistically
accomplish, though it would be a group effort.
College used to be the place to go
for the minority of people who really wanted higher education. Those who wanted
to be lawyers, doctors, or simply valued knowledge above other things went to
college. For the majority, they had no use for college, and that made absolute
sense. Do you really need college to work in a factory or cubicle? Probably
not. However, as time went on, more colleges began to appear and eventually it
became engrained in society that we have to go to college to get a good job
because we will be competing with other people who have college degrees. But
still, why do you need a college education if all you are doing is filling out
an Excel spreadsheet? As of now, college is attended by basically everyone,
despite the fact that most students can’t afford it and are in terrible debt
paying for a degree that they couldn’t give two shits about. Right now, college
is an extension of high school.
So how can we improve? In order to
do this we would have to totally change employer’s minds about the value of a
degree. People with college degrees should not be looking for jobs in retail or
jobs where it simply isn’t required, and employers should understand when the
job they’re hiring for isn’t something that requires a degree. Right now, high
schools are all about setting people up for college. Every step of the way
you’re encouraged to think about where you want to go and what you want to do.
The tests like the SAT and AP exams are mandatory to get you to a good college.
As a fix, maybe the SAT and AP exams should only be available to those students
with great grades and an intention to go on to higher education.
There are plenty of things that
need to be changed in order to fix the mindset that college is mandatory. Most
importantly, the amount of schools should be drastically decreased, and those
schools that are still left should have a far lower acceptance rate. If less
people are getting into college, then hopefully people will realize that going
to college just isn’t as important and employers will begin to relax their
hiring policies.
This was super disorganized I
think, but my main point is that college should not be thought of as mandatory,
and if we can get less people feeling like they are forced to go, maybe we can
go back to the days when only those who wanted to be there would be in college.
Hmm... It's a challenge, right? I mean, in the past, the small minority who attended college was basically a self-perpetuating wealthy oligarchy. It wasn't the people who "wanted" certain jobs; people ended up with certain jobs because they had the financial resources to make those dreams possible. To a certain extent this is still true; fewer Americans go to college (and even fewer graduate) than you may think. Among 25-year olds, I still think it's only about 50%? And it's still a system that's largely fueled by class, money, and family background.
ReplyDeleteI do agree that things need to change, and many people attend college than need to. See my comment on AJ's post about the idea of a gap year - I think that could solve a lot of problems. What do y'all think?
I definitely agree that college shouldn't be seen as the mandatory next step after high school. Like Dr. MB says, I think that it's still a very classist system, as well as one that favors the ones whose intelligence is more academic instead of one of the other- but still valid!- types of intelligences.
ReplyDeleteYour point about high school being completely centered around college. For those students who may not be interested or able to go to college, this is really alienating. School is really not for everyone but society sees those who don't pursue higher education as failures, instead of people who may be successful in other areas such as in their jobs or creative projects. And what happens to those who are unable to work or "contribute" in a way accepted by society in a capitalist system that puts down anyone who doesn't do so?
Basically the whole system sucks and I agree that college should be treated as less of a necessity.
Oops, I forgot to finish the first sentence of my second paragraph! I was trying to say that I agreed with that point! (Next time I will proofread.)
DeleteI disagree with this idea somewhat. While I do recognize that not every job requires college level education, I think the issue should be looked at from societal standpoint rather than a job task standpoint. Yes, college drains money unnecessarily from some people but many valuable experiences come as a result. Going to college removes people from the town they have grown up in and places them in a new environment that is conducive to expanding perspectives and transitions the students into adulthood. Without this important step, those two important societal aspects suffer. I think the real problem is the cost. College should be either free or low-cost because it is a necessary institution for acclimation into adult life.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your main point, that college should not be "thought of as necessary" but for many jobs, I do think more schooling of some sort is necessary. Yes, it is quite frustrating that many people think it is the end of the world if they don't go to college and that their lives will be miserable, but there are a number of jobs that really aren't possible to obtain fresh out of high school (I know I certainly wouldn't be ready to be a doctor right after I graduated High School). Perhaps a better thing to do would be to say that college isn't necessary for all jobs, but more schooling of some sort is necessary for other jobs.
ReplyDelete