College,
an institution that is hardly necessary for most people in the first place,
should come at a considerably cheaper price (or preferably none at all). We
wouldn’t be the first nation to suggest or adopt such a policy, and the
benefits would be phenomenal, since more college grads would be hanging their
diplomas in their own studies rather than above their parents’ couch, aka their
bed. This couch (aka bed, aka dining room) will need to be replaced rather
quickly as the new grad finds himself rarely moving from it, since he’ll
probably have extreme difficulty finding a job at all (let alone one in his
desired field, good job on that Philosophy major) and then even more difficulty
saving any of the money he makes, since it has to go right back into paying off
loans and debts to the school that devastated his parents’ and his own bank
accounts for four years and printed an often-meaningless piece of paper at the
end.
Obviously it’s important to get a
job that requires a college degree. After all, you’re going to need a job to
make all of the money necessary to pay off that college degree you just got. This
puts you into an interesting loop of circular reasoning where you need a job to
make money to pay off loans that you needed to get an education for a job that
you use to make money to pay off loans that you needed to get an education to
get a job that you use to pay off loans, etc. It’s the kind of futile struggle
that makes you want to hang yourself, except you can’t afford a chair or a
rope; besides, you’ve got work tomorrow, and the next day, and forever.
We tend to think of college as a
mandatory thing nowadays, looking down at people who choose not to pursue higher
education, or simply cannot afford to. I know countless students that turn
their noses up at people who attend community colleges rather than a “real”
college, when more often than not they’re paying (at least) close to quadruple
the tuition for an identical education. People go through years of college
undecided (as I did), because their parents insisted they go, despite their not
having a clue about what they want to study, often enough sleeping through
class (if they attend) or playing Candy Crush on their iPad, assuming they didn't
sell it for tuition money (thanks Hood!).
"But you absolutely have to go to college or you’re a total loser!" ...who isn't paying thousands of your parents’ dollars to get
an education you could have gotten off Wikipedia? Only, Wikipedia doesn't print diplomas (yet), which is literally all college is
necessary for, so keep spending, I guess.
If we could make college a cheaper
experience, and emphasize that it is not necessary
or even ideal for everyone, we could
simultaneously lower the number of students pursuing degrees they aren’t interested
in, lower the amount of crippling debt countless American students are living
under, and generally make the experience of college into one with considerably
less stress and demand. We could stop looking down at people who choose not to pursue “higher education,”
because there are plenty of jobs in this country and in this world that neither
require nor make use of book-smarts.
I think this video by YouTube user nigahiga sums it all up quite nicely and amusingly:
I think this video by YouTube user nigahiga sums it all up quite nicely and amusingly:
One step I would recommend here is a mandatory (or at least STRONGLY RECOMMENDED) gap year between high school and college. This is pretty normal in other countries and I think that it helps kids (and their parents) become aware of what the options are and which ones actually do need a college education (2-year, 4-year, or beyond) and which don't. Most of us don't have a chance to even know who we are outside of school until we're 21 or 22. That's kinda crazy. People make a lot of assumptions about themselves based on who they are while they are in school, but that person won't be you forever!!
ReplyDeleteThis is so depressing to read because it's true. I live in constant fear of living in a box without a job since I've double-majored in two liberal arts subjects and aspire to write for a dying medium. I think that if college has become such a staple, then it should be free. I also agree with Dr. MB about gap time. It should be mandatory to have some reflection and travel time in between high school. While I have always known what I want to study, I am one of a rare few. I know so many of my friends had trouble declaring and that a lot of them will be undergraduates for 5 or 6 years just to play catchup. I think we should only pay for things that are additional to the minimum requirement. If every employer wants someone who has an undergraduate degree, then an undergraduate degree should be a free guaranteed right for all or affordable on a sliding scale of some sort. If an employer wants a graduate degree, then that should be free too. I think it would've been so much nicer to go to college for free so I would not have this constant fear of paying for my graduate and doctorate degrees hanging over my head. If we want everyone to have something, we should make it easier to obtain.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIs it not crazy how as college became "mandatory", the price also skyrocketed? Tuition has risen over 700% in the last 30 years, much higher than the rate of inflation. I definitely identify with a lot of sentiments here. I can not help but feel a little helpless. I have not resorted to selling my iPad for tuition money, but I know that fear that comes with getting a college degree. I am "lucky" enough that I will only be coming out of undergrad with lower than average loans, but it still hurts.
ReplyDeleteI want to be an animal behaviorist, so undergrad and grad school are necessary, unfortunately. However, for some people, it becomes really apparent freshman year that college is not for them and they would be happier doing something that does not require it. A gap year is a fabulous thing. AJ, I definitely agree with the pressure to go to college right out of high school is fueled by the "you'll be a loser" attitude. So many do not have the drive that college requires right out of high school. They tell us we have so much time to decide our majors; it doesn't matter if you don't know what you want to do yet!!! This is very untrue as Logan pointed out. A gap year would definitely help us to discover our passions outside an academic setting so that if/when we go to college, we do not waste time with classes and decide that we want to switch majors and end up in college longer than the "Four life changing years".
We definitely need to either change our attitudes regarding everyone needing to go to college, or make college easier for students to obtain. It is unfair to push so much debt on a generation that did not even create the competition that made a bachelors degree necessary. We are just struggling to gain enough speed to jump in and join the race that began with previous generations.
I think that this is so, very true. I constantly find myself planning my future (which may be more secure than most, graduating with a teaching degree), and scared to death about finding a job that will allow me to pay for school. I cannot imagine doing all of the work that I have done to graduate and finding myself without a job. I think that a gap year is brilliant. I think that so many people would benefit from this because they would be allowed to see what the world has to offer beyond classroom walls. There is so much more to this world than textbooks and grades. I think that the year off would really promote this.
ReplyDeleteWhenever this topic comes up, I get very angry because in a country where college is "mandatory," like ours, it not only makes the lives of those that attend it more difficult (In most cases), but it helps to promote the classism that is so prominent in this country. I find it very unfortunate that we tell people who come from the lower class or situations not akin to our own that they must attend college in order to move themselves up in the world yet we charge them an exorbitant amount of money that they do not have to do so. This is not fair, and is just another one of the many problems that this idea of mandatory college imposes on the people of this country.